By Nakiwala Barbra
Eight years after Disney’s Moana became a global phenomenon, its sequel has arrived to mixed reviews. While the film reunites Moana (Auli’i Cravalho) and Maui (Dwayne Johnson) for a new adventure to save islanders oppressed by the evil god Nalo, critics have noted that Moana 2 lacks the originality and emotional resonance of the 2016 classic.
The Telegraph praised it as a “giddily animated triumph” with an exhilarating pace and catchy songs, but even its positive review hinted at a diminished freshness.
Not all critics were as forgiving. The Guardian criticized the sequel as a “frictionless” and passionless continuation, with reviewer Peter Bradshaw describing it as a “perky ChatGPT iteration of love, laughter, and belonging.” Similarly, Variety described the movie as “dutiful rather than inspired,” noting the absence of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical magic, which made the original’s songs unforgettable.
Many reviews agreed that the sequel feels more like a product aimed at younger audiences than a heartfelt story.
Some critics appreciated the sequel’s entertaining visuals and fast pace, calling it an enjoyable, if less impactful, follow-up. The Telegraph and BBC Culture highlighted its vibrant animation and family-friendly themes, while acknowledging its lack of the first film’s emotional depth. Screen Daily, however, argued that Moana’s once-charming journey has become overly convoluted and stilted, resulting in a story that feels less bold and meaningful.
Despite the mixed reception, Moana 2 is expected to make waves at the box office, with projections of $135-$145 million in its opening weekend. Its theatrical release pits it against Wicked, another major musical adaptation, ensuring competition for holiday audiences.
For fans of the original, Moana 2 may still offer enough vibrant visuals and adventure to please, but critics agree it doesn’t quite recapture the magic of its predecessor.
